The Last Lecture and First Penguins

-

image from tldp.org

I'm reading the Last Lecture book and can relate to Randy Pausch in quite a few ways.  Although I'm thankful not to have any terminal illness,  I can relate because I have children of similar age, teach, and I also grew up in Pittsburgh.  One thing of the many that I appreciate about his comments was his First Penguin Award that he gave out to the "glorious failures,"  those students who took a daring risk at doing something innovative yet crashed and burned.

The education world consistently rewards success and punishes failures.  Whether it's SAT's or English papers or designing products.  It encourages students to do the safe thing.  Do the easy, conservative solution.  Do what the professor "likes." Uninspiring, yet slightly better than what was done before.  Design school can foster the same environment.   And you end up getting a dozen graduates whose portfolios look nearly identical.  Students are scared to death of failing, so they tone it down, and spend too much time rendering a crummy computer model.

How can I encourage these students to take risks? To take a chance and go bold?  I think it's like doing tricks on a snowboard.  If there's no fresh, soft snow to cushion my landing when trying to do an air, I'm scared to try it.  Especially when it's "hard pack granular" snow, like all you New Englanders are all too familiar with (AKA ice.)  If I try something and fall, I'm going to hurt, and may end up in a ski patrol toboggan, so unless I have a disregard for my safety, I'm not going to try that switch 360.

But if there's plentiful powder, it's another story.  I'll try it, because the consequences of failing aren't so bad, maybe a tumble and a face full of snow.  So how do you do it at the Unversity?  This should be the place for students to safely fail, because that's where the learning happens.  Pausch gave out a stuffed penguin to the team that tried hard but failed, maybe it's a bitter sweet consolation prize, but it's at least an acknowledgement.

Is the goal of education success or is it learning?  If it's learning, then success or failure is a minor consequence.  Do we want more designers in self-preservation mode, or ones that will innovate our way out of this collective economic and environmental mess?

Comments

Jeffrey said…
hi, my name is jeff and this is pretty much the first ID-related blog that i find rather inspiring and interesting to read. just wanting to say thanks for contributing.
January 30, 2009 at 8:58 AM
Jason Morris said…
Thanks for the encouragement, Jeffrey!
January 31, 2009 at 8:29 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vehicle Designs of Star Wars: The Force Awakens - Variations on the Familiar

-
Image
As we eagerly await the opening of Star Wars: The Force Awakens, I noticed some interesting visual relationships in the vehicle designs shown in the trailer. It seems that the creative direction has been "variations on a familiar theme." The designers have taken the old vehicles from episodes 4 - 6 and done small modifications to upgrade them for 30 years later. copyright Lucasfilm Rey's Speeder Rey's speeder is essentially the same form as Luke's but turned 90 degrees. Changing from a convertible 2 seater to a single rider vehicle. The weathered, desaturated orange body color is similar. The yellow orange striping is the same. And even the hemispherical wind screen is the same shape. Also notice how the strip grill in the front is the same. Perhaps they are the same manufacturer? copyright Lucasfilm It seems that Rey could have used something with more cargo space, being a scavenger. Such as a pick-up truck speeder, but maybe the Sanford a
Read more

Furniture Design Exhibition Seattle - Western ID graduates 2022 - part 2

-
Image
Chair, ottoman, and side table of aluminum and wood by Keaton LoCicero. The industrial design class of Western Washington University 2022 exhibited their final chair design prototypes at HenryBuilt in Seattle, WA, USA. June 10.  A one night only exhibition. Keaton spent hours polishing the interior surfaces of the aluminum. sketch models by Keaton LoCicero Chair and side table by Wylie Jacoy. Rocking chair of aluminum and woven fabric by Adele Houston.  An aluminum vase by Adele Houston Chair and ottoman design by Lili Heim. Constructed of bent polycarbonate and aluminum. Chair, ottoman, and side table design by Asaki Nelson. Constructed of CNC plywood. process photos and artifacts. Display posters Chair design by Matthew Seeman. detail. Constructed of cast aluminum and wood. All photos by Jason Morris. Please attribute the designer if re-posting. Follow Western Industrial Design program on Instagram:  wwu id (@wwuid) • Instagram photos and videos Join our ID program:  Industrial Desig
Read more

Furniture Design Exhibition - Western ID graduates 2022 - part 1

-
Image
  Chair and ottoman design by Kelsey Leppek 2022 The industrial design class of Western Washington University 2022 exhibited their final chair design prototypes at HenryBuilt in Seattle, WA, USA. June 10.  A one night only exhibition. This set was made with bent steel tubing and fabric cushions. It was a packed crowd at the first graduate exhibition for WWU ID since 2019. Side chair by Brianna Brown 2022. Bent plywood connection detail. Brianna Brown. Bent plywood chair by Rafer Stromme. The two plywood forms are connected with a cast aluminum form. Transformable furniture design by Trinity Montgomery 2022. By changing the orientation and tying the braided rope this piece converts to various forms. Arm chair and side table by Dylan Willis 2022. This chair is made from aluminum sheet, cushions, and bolted together. It can be disassembled and packaged flat. Lounge chair of bent steel and felt by Bo Baird 2022. Each piece of felt strip was hand cut and connected with brass fasteners. All
Read more